Doc family suicide pact: Debt theory baffles police, relatives

[email protected] (Deccan Herald)
December 4, 2011

suicide1

Bangalore, December 4: What drove the family of three doctors and a would-be medical graduate to suicide? Was it debt or something else?

Police as well as the relatives of the dead are equally dumbfounded at the hints that the family ended their lives in a suicide pact because of their inability to repay a debt said to be in the range of Rs one crore to Rs five crore. But no one is sure. Naziya, 22, who was adopted by Mohammad Amanullah and Naveeda Banu 11 years ago because the couple did not have a daughter, says she is not sure about the family’s debt.

She said the couple had borrowed money to educate their sons Mohammad Ehtesham Rasheed (28), who graduated from M S Ramaiah College, Bangalore, and Mohammad Afham Rasheed (26), who was pursuing final-year MBBS at Sri Devaraj Urs Medical College, Kolar.

But the family struggled to repay the loans and borrowed more. “They used to talk among themselves about it (the debt),” Naziya said in her statement to the police.

Fayyaz Ahmad, husband of Amanullah’s sister-in-law, put the family debt at between Rs 80 lakh and Rs one crore. But was the liability indeed the reason for their suicides? Fayyaz too is not sure. “It was not a debt they couldn’t have repaid.

I’d be shocked to know they ended their lives for this,” Fayyaz told Deccan Herald. Buoyed by the success of their hospital, Khuda Care Nursing Home, the family had opened another health centre at Shamanna Garden where Dr Amanullah used to practise more.

It employed several nurses and other staff who were provided accommodation on the third floor of the building.

Police, on their part, are also clueless about the reason for the suicides. With no death note found, they concluded, after enquiring with the relatives and neighbours of the deceased, that the family’s decision was driven most likely by their inability to repay the loans.

Naziya’s mother died when she was about seven years old. Her father, Noorullah, abandoned her. The doctor couple then adopted her. She studied till 7th class. She denied any issues with the family and said she stayed with them quite happily.

Dr Amanullah and his sons left home for an unknown place at 7.30 am on Thursday. When they returned around 11.30 pm, Naziya enquired about supper. But Amanullah asked her to go to bed. When she persisted, he sternly asked her to not disturb him. “Main poochhna chahti thi magar unhon gusse mein the, isliye khamosh rag gayi” (I wanted to persist with the queries but had to keep quiet because of his annoyance), Naziya said.

Minutes after she entered her bedroom, it was bolted from outside. She pleaded Amanullah to open the door but there was no response. When asked if she realised that something was amiss then, Naziya said: “I was very confused and apprehensive but that (suicide) did not strike my mind. The only thing which distrurbed me was the baffling silence.”

The family injected the paralytic drug, Succinylcholine, with three syringes. Police found the syringes, along with five 10ml vials of the drug, four of them empty, at the spot. Although the drug is not available in the market, the deceased, being medical practitioners themselves, might have procured it easily.

Naziya says her adopted family did not have food last night. They did not even change their clothes. Amanullah wore formal clothes and slept in one corner, flanked to the right by his wife who wore a salwar kameez. Ehtesham slept next to his mother and Afham, who wore jeans, on the far right. They slept with their feet towards a sofa.

Suicide pact stuns residents of Valmiki Nagar


The suicide by what people described a ''family of doctors'' has stunned the residents of Valmiki Nagar, a congested neighbourhood off Mysore Road with a sizeable Muslim population.

As the news spread, people thronged the Khuda Care Nursing Home. M Chandrappa, a neighbour, said that the news made everyone rush to the narrow lane where the hospital is located. Chandrappa was among the first who heard the news and rushed to the spot. “It was a frightening scene,” he said.

Dr Amanullah, the head of the family, had two brothers, both doctors. One of them lives in the Gulf and the other in Bellary. He had three sisters.

Amanullah’s wife, Naveeda Banu, had three brothers, Majid Ahmad, Saleem Ahmad, and Jamsheed Ahmad, and three sisters, Nousheed, Anjum, and Asfiya. The family lives on KT Street, Mysore. Most of them arrived in the City upon hearing the news.


Near-stampede

People jostled for space when the bodies were brought from Victoria Hospital and laid outside for public viewing. It was a near-stampede as men and women struggled to catch a glimpse of the dead.

Banu’s body was lined first but men were prohibited from catching a glimpse, in accordance with the Islamic principles. This further crowded the place as women found it hard to move on and men to stride past.

The bodies were taken to Mysore in an ambulance.

Laid to rest in Mysore

Mysore: Last rites of four of a doctor’s family who killed selves in?Bangalore on Thursday midnight, were performed at a burial ground in the city on?Saturday.

The mortal remains of Dr Mohammed?Amanullah (61) his wife Naveeda?Banu (50), their sons Mohammed Ehtesham Rasheed (28) and Mohammed Afham Rasheed (26) were brought to the residence of Mohammed Adil Rasheed, on?K?T?Street in the city on Friday night.

Rasheed is the father of Naveeda Banu. The last rites were performed at the burial ground near Tipu?Circle in?N?R?Mohalla.

The doctor’s family had killed selves after allegedly injecting themselves with a paralytic drug at their house-cum-hospital at fourth cross, second main, Valmiki Nagar in Bangalore. The doctor owed huge debt to the tune of not more than Rs one crore, the reason behind their extreme step, according to a relative.

Comments

Antonetta
 - 
Saturday, 5 Mar 2016

Badz osobnik predko ja nosi jakze w bieglosci sie bada i czyzby sa doplate UE
natomiast który jest wydatek takiej oczyszczalni bede wdzieczna za kazda wzmianke Oczyszczalnia o której mówisz istnieje super,mam 1-rok
ale pozostaje troszczyc o bakterie

Feel free to visit my web site: oczyszczanie scieków przemyslowych: http://www.cgzxw.net/comment/html/?2118.html&page=

Madison
 - 
Friday, 15 Jan 2016

Egzystujemy indywidualnoscia ustawiona w nieduzej drogi od
Wytrwania natomiast mamy sie zwykle budowa szamb dietetycznych, bliskie oczyszczalnie przydomowe wychodza samemu od rozdzielaczy równiez z ich wytwórców

Also visit my web page; oczyszczalnia przydomowa: http://shop.jndzh.com/comment/html/?2269.html

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
News Network
April 5,2020

Nagpur, Apr 5: A 23-year-old man allegedly committed suicide in Imambada area in Nagpur on Saturday due to financial distress, police said.

Nikhil Gavhane, who worked in a grocery shop, hanged himself as he had taken money from a person and was stressed over repayment, an official said.

"He was depressed since a week," the Imambada police station official said.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
Agencies
January 8,2020

Muzaffarpur, Jan 8: There is no evidence of murder of children in Bihar's Muzaffarpur shelter home, the CBI on Wednesday told the Supreme Court.

The probe agency told the apex court that two skeletons were recovered from the home's premises which were later, in forensic investigation, found to be of a woman and a man.

A bench headed by Chief Justice S A Bobde accepted the status report of the CBI and allowed two officers to be relieved from the investigation team.

Attorney General K K Venugopal, appearing for the probe agency, said investigation was done on allegations of rape and sexual assault of children and charge sheets have been filed before the courts concerned.

Venugopal said the children, who were alleged to have been murdered, were later traced and found to be alive.

He said the CBI has investigated cases of 17 shelter homes in Bihar and charge sheets have been filed in 13 of them, while in four cases the preliminary inquiry was conducted and later closed as no evidence of any wrongdoing was found.

The probe agency, in its status report filed on Monday, said no incriminating evidence proving commission of any criminal offence could be gathered in four preliminary enquiries and as such no FIR has been registered.

The CBI had also said the Bihar government has been requested to take departmental action and action of cancellation of registration and blacklisting of concerned NGOs by providing them the result of investigation, i.e., the CBI report.

Several girls were allegedly sexually and physically assaulted at a shelter home run by an NGO in Bihar's Muzaffarpur. The issue had come to light following a report by the Tata Institute of Social Sciences (TISS).

Following the report, a petition was filed in the apex court seeking lodging of an FIR and court-monitored probe by an independent agency into the allegations.

The plea filed by journalist Nivedita Jha through advocate Fauzia Shakil has sought "registration of FIR and independent investigations or court monitored probe into the affairs of these 14 (other) shelter homes in Bihar mentioned in the TISS report".

The apex court had directed the CBI to probe the offences under the Information Technology Act regarding the video recordings of the alleged assault on girls at the shelter home.

It had also directed the agency to investigate the role of "outsiders who were involved and facilitated the sexual assaults on the inmates", after administering them intoxicants and also against those who allegedly indulged in trafficking of girls from the shelter home.

The apex court had earlier directed the CBI to complete its probe into the alleged murder of 11 girls at the shelter home and asked it to file a status report.

The SC had transferred the case from Bihar to a Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) court in Saket District Court complex in Delhi.

Earlier, the top court had directed the CBI to conduct a probe into allegations of physical and sexual abuse of inmates in 16 other shelter homes in Bihar which were flagged in the TISS report.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
News Network
February 10,2020

Mumbai, Feb 10: Ankita Pisudde, a resident of Hinganghat town in Wardha, was critical after sustaining 40% burns on February 3 when she was set afire, allegedly by one Vikesh Nagrale (27) while she was on her way to college.

The 25-year-old woman lecturer who was set on fire by a stalker in Maharashtra’s Wardha district last week died at a hospital in Nagpur on Monday morning, a police official said.

Ankita Pisudde, resident of Hinganghat town in Wardha, had been critical after sustaining 35 to 40% “grade III” burns on February 3 when she was set afire allegedly by one Vikesh Nagrale (27) while she was on way to her college, they said.

She was undergoing treatment at the Orange City Hospital & Research Centre here, located around 75 km from Wardha.

“Doctors at the hospital declared her dead at 6.55 a.m. today,” Hinganghat’s police inspector Satyaveer Bandiwar said.

The woman sustained deep burn injuries on scalp, face, right upper limb, left hand, upper back, neck and eyes along with severe inhalational injuries, the hospital said in a medical bulletin on Monday.

She died of “septicemic shock” after suffering from deep dermal burns along with severe inhalational injuries, respiratory distress and related complications, it said.

Around 4 a.m. on Monday, her oxygen levels deteriorated inspite of ventilator support, coupled with decreasing urine output and reduction in blood pressure, the hospital said.

As part of immediate resuscitation measures, medicines were escalated to maintain the blood pressure and all feasible steps were taken to improve the oxygen levels in blood, but the patient remained “extremely critical”, it said.

“Around 6.30 a.m., she had bradycardia and inspite of prolonged cardiopulmonary resuscitation, the patient could not be revived and was declared dead at 6.55 a.m.,” it said.

The probable cause of death was “septicemic shock”, the bulletin added.

During her treatment, she underwent tracheostomy (creating an opening in neck to place a tube into the windpipe to allow air to enter the lungs), burn dressings, debridement and escharotomies, the hospital informed.

Debridement is a medical procedure to remove dead, damaged or infected tissue, while escharotomy is a surgical procedure used to treat full-thickness (third-degree) circumferential burns.

The woman’s parents and uncle were kept informed about her deteriorating health condition and death, the hospital said, adding that the body was later handed over to police for postmortem and other formalities.

After the woman’s condition deteriorated, the hospital informed about her critical status to Maharashtra Home Minister Anil Deshmukh, Wardha Guardian Minister Sunil Kedar, Nagpur Divisional Commissioner Sanjeev Kumar, Police Commissioner Bhushan Kumar Upadhyay, Wardha Collector Vivek Bhimanwar and Wardha Superintendent of Police Basavraj Teli.

Heavy security was deployed in Hinganghat to avoid any law and order problem following her death, the police said.

Several locals, mostly women and college students, took out a march in Wardha city last Thursday, demanding death penalty for the accused.

Home Minister Deshmukh visited the hospital on Tuesday and announced that the accused’s trial would be fast-tracked.

The State government last week flew Navi Mumbai-based National Burns Centre director Sunil Keswani to Nagpur to supervise the woman’s treatment.

It has also appointed well-known lawyer Ujjwal Nikam as special public prosecutor in the case.

According to the victim’s relatives, Nagrale, who was arrested within hours of the incident on February 3, had been harassing her for quite some time.

Nagrale and the woman were friends till two years ago when she severed ties with him due to his “irrational behaviour”, the police earlier said.

A special team led by Deputy Superintendent of Police Trupti Jadhav will probe the case, the Wardha Police said last week.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.