'Harry was pushed from 11th floor window'

May 31, 2012

fatal_fall

Dubai, May 31: Investigations into a British teenager’s fatal fall from a Motor City building have taken a new twist. The police are now believed to be probing a murder angle. At the centre of their investigation is a ‘mysterious brawl’ that allegedly led to the boy’s suspicious death, XPRESS can reveal.

A student of Jumeirah College, Harry Harling, 15, was found dead on the lawn of Newbridge Hill 1 residential building in Motor City on March 24. Sources told XPRESS that investigators are in possession of CCTV footage showing three men moving around in the building lobby after midnight when Harry and his friends were having a party in an apartment there.

On March 23 evening, 42 teenagers from Dubai’s five leading expat schools turned up at an apartment on the 7th floor of Newbridge Hill 2 for a sleep-over party, the sources said. XPRESS is withholding the apartment number and the name of its Western owner as the case is under police investigation.

A next-door neighbour told XPRESS she saw the partygoers arriving in taxis and shouting up from the car park to the balcony of the apartment from where loud music was blaring.

According to the sources, the fun-filled evening took an ugly turn when a couple and a third person complained about the loud music and noise. This soon turned in to a brawl between them. It is believed that soon after, Harry was thrown from a West-facing window on the 11th floor of Newbridge Hill 1 building.

The sources also said a student reported that he overheard a conversation at a men’s salon that Harry was drugged and pushed from the common area’s window on the 11th floor of the Newbridge Hill 1 building.

Moreover, the police have recorded statements of a 16-year-old boy who was at the party. He said that there were three clashes between the students that evening. According to the sources, the boy told the police: “At no time were they supervised or helped by the host. After the brawls, Harry was left outside and allowed to leave to get a taxi when in fact his parents had given him permission to ‘stay the night’ at his friend’s house. The parents were not informed that Harry had left the party and believed him to be safe for the night. Sadly they did not know he was dead outside the building until telephoned the next day by the Dubai Police.”

A Swiss couple, residents of Newbridge Hill, meanwhile, told XPRESS they had heard loud “fun-filled” noises coming from a flat on the top floor of the building when they were taking a stroll to Spinneys at the nearby Foxhill building on March 23. However, the noise sounded like a “major brawl”, when they returned later, the couple said.

On March 24, this XPRESS reporter saw black powder fingerprint traces left by forensic experts, which suggested the boy did fall from that particular window on a grass patch directly below the top floor window of Newbridge Hill 1. A close look revealed that the window hinges were broken.

A lawyer who is working with prosecutors in the case told XPRESS: “Harry can in no way jump out of the window — it’s far too high for him to even climb up. There is more to the incident that meets the eyes. Everyone — his friends, parents, teachers and even neighbours are certain something untoward took place.”

“No one saw the body before 8.30am. How is that possible as a lot of people had passed through the area during that time, including the police,” a neighbour said, adding that the police visited the area twice that night — first, when the watchman had to call them as there was fighting in another party in a Foxhill apartment; and second, when a lorry met with an accident near the Motor City roundabout.

“We firmly believe that our son would not have been on his own after saying: ‘I’m getting a taxi, I’m going home’. We have full faith in Dubai Police and know the officials are doing their best. However, it simply doesn’t make sense for Harry to say he is getting a cab home and then his body being found at the bottom of the building. Something must have happened in between. How can anyone let a 15-year-old boy die at a public place and not report it? I appeal to all those who may have seen or been present when the incident took place to come forward and help bring justice to Harry. Please help if you have seen Harry between midnight and 9.30am on 24/03/2012. For any information, anonymous or otherwise, please contact XPRESS,” Harry’s father Nicolus Harling’s appeal letter stated on Wednesday.



Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
News Network
July 17,2020

Ahmadabad, July 17: The Gujarat high court has ordered the Bharuch superintendent of police to investigate and produce a 14-year-old girl before the court, who has allegedly eloped with a man. Ironically, the man was convicted two years ago on Pocso charges for eloping with another minor girl in 2016.

The high court has asked the government to file an application for bail cancellation of the convict because he has indulged in a similar offence after having come out on bail.

The case involved one Dilip Padhiyar (24) from Uchchhad village in Jambusar taluka of Bharuch district.

He was punished with 10 years in jail in December 2018 by a special court for kidnapping a 16-year-old girl in 2016. He was prosecuted under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Pocso) Act and for rape and kidnapping charges. He got away with a 10-year-imprisonment because the girl was over 16 years and she had not alleged rape. However, Dilip Padhiyar was held guilty of statutory rape, abduction as well as under provisions of Pocso Act.

Dinesh Padhiyar got regular bail from the high court pending his appeal challenging his conviction in January 2019. In November 2019, he eloped with another minor girl.

Her father approached the high court complaining that though an FIR was registered with Vedach police station, the police have not made any effort to trace his minor girl. It was also contended in the habeas corpus petition that Padhiyar is a habitual offender.

Petitioner's advocate Imtiyaz Kureshi said that looking at the past of Dinesh Padhiyar, the high court asked the state government to initiate proceedings for cancellation of his bail.

The bench headed by Justice Sonia Gokani instructed HC's registry to treat the bail cancellation application as an urgent matter.

The high court has ordered Bharuch SP to produce the girl before the court by July 20, and in case she cannot be traced by then, he will have to submit an action taken report.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
Agencies
May 14,2020

Six migrant workers have been killed and five others seriously injured when a speeding bus ran over them on the Delhi-Saharanpur Highway near in Muzaffarnagar, officials said on Thursday.

The accused driver, who was suspected to be under the influence of alcohol, has been arrested, said SSP Abhishek Yadav.

The workers were going on foot to their homes in Bihar from Haryana when they were hit on the Delhi-Saharanpur Highway between Ghalili Check Post and Rohana Toll Plaza, about 20 km from here late last night, the official said.

The injured -- Sushil, Nathu Saini, Pawan Saini, Pramod and Ramji Rai --were rushed to hospital.

Two of the deceased were identified as Bijender, 25, and Harsh, 20. The rest were yet to be identified.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
Agencies
May 25,2020

Hyderabad, May 25: Indicating foul play in the death of nine people, including six of a family, whose bodies were fished out from a well near Warangal, a forensic expert on Sunday virtually ruled out suicide theory, saying it appeared seven of them had been dragged and thrown into the water body.

Mystery shrouded the death of nine people, including six of a family, whose bodies were found in a well, five of them on Friday and four on Thursday, on the outskirts of Warangal in Telangana.

Police stepped up the probe and forensic analysis was also underway in the case.

The forensic expert, who visited the crime scene as part of the investigation citing preliminary tests, said that the seven of nine people had scratch injuries and appeared to have been "dragged" and "thrown" into the well.

Forensic reports are expected in 10 days, the forensic expert told media on Sunday adding after examining the crime scene it appears that the deaths were not suicides.

"We have preserved all organs and the same were sent to forensic science laboratory (FSL) for examination... some two or three persons might have been involved in the crime. There are scratch injuries on the bodies," he said.

"It appears that they were thrown into the water... There were no injuries on the child's body. We are awaiting the forensic report (to ascertain) whether they were poisoned. It didn't appear as if they committed suicide," the expert, who performed the post-mortem said.

Police sources said at least two people were picked up for questioning.

Bodies of the head of the family, wife, daughter and three-year old grandson were found floating and fished out on Thursday.

On Friday morning, some bodies were seen floating following which police pumped out the water from the well and found others.

The 48-year old man had migrated from West Bengal over 20 years ago and had settled down here. His family had been staying in two rooms on the premises of the unit, police had earlier said.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.