Condemn all forms of communalism: Irfan Engineer

March 28, 2012

Canara2

Mangalore, March 28: Communalism is rampant not just in India but in other South Asian countries like Pakistan and Bangladesh too. While condemning communalism, one must condemn the idea of communalism itself and not a particular type of communalism perpetrated by a particular group or religious ideology, said Irfan Engineer, advocate and Director, Institute for Peace Studies and Conflict, Mumbai.

He was speaking at a seminar on Peace and Conflict Resolution organised by Canara Organisation for Development and Peace in Mangalore on Wednesday.

Stating that communalism exists in Pakistan and Bangladesh too, Mr. Engineer said “In Pakistan, the Taliban and Lashkar-e-Toiba are to be blamed for communalism. The rights of minority Hindus are not being protected there. In Bangladesh, I would condemn Jamaat-e-Islami for the communalism existing there. All those political organisations which victimize innocent people anywhere in the world are to be condemned”, he said.

Mr. Engineer also said that although he may not agree with the concept of M F Hussain's controversial painting or Salman Rushdie's controversial writings, he defends their right to say what they want to, as they are exercising the value of liberty that secular constitutions vouch for. “One should have the right to say things about me even if they offend me,” he said.

Shedding light on the concept of 'Hindutva' ideology, Mr. Engineer said that according to its own conceptualizers such as M S Golwalkar, V D Savarkar and others, it is 'a political strategy and has got nothing to do with religion'. He substantiated his claim by citing the tricolor hoisting issue at Eidgah Maidan at Hubli. “Show me one RSS office where the national tricolor is hoisted any day in the year. They have no regard for the tricolor as they are against the Constitution of India as a whole. The BJP which made a hue and cry about the issue then, forgot about it after coming to power,” he said.

Mr. Engineer said that the RSS 'creates' its targets and works accordingly. “If there are no terrorists they will create terrorists so that they get a pretext to attack Muslims. If there is no New Life Church, they will create one. They want New Life to exist. They will finance people to make sure that these things happen. The blast probes in Malegaon and other places have revealed that RSS made its men don Muslim appearances and carried out the bomb blasts. They 'create' Muslim and Christian extremists. They thrive on the idea of playing on emotions and projecting wrong history,” Mr. Engineer claimed.

Talking about communalism in the pre-Independence era, Mr. Engineer said that primarily two types of nationalism concepts emerged at the time to challenge the British imperialism. “On one hand, there was the feudal system that was followed in the country for long which had also traditional and religious affiliations to it. On the other hand, there was the secular inclusive nationalism. The Hindu Maha Sabha and the Muslim League were parties that represented this religious and traditional nationalism and parties such as the Indian National Congress of Gandhiji and Nehru, Dr Ambedkar's Republican Party of India, Bhagat Singh's Hindustan Socialist Republican Association, the Communist Party of India etc proposed secular nationalism. Even today, the former wants to defend their traditions which would mean inequality. However, India as a whole has a history of opposing hierarchy traditions. When people talk about 'Indian Nationalism' why don't they consider Buddhism, Jainism, Basavanna's and Charvaka's teachings? Aren't they part of Indian nationalism too?” Mr. Engineer questioned.

Stressing that there is a need to bring about a change in attitude as far as communalism is concerned, Mr. Engineer said “Although innocents are killed during communal riots, most people do not feel bad about the fact that lives have been lost. They see these losses of lives in the prism of communalism. If a Muslim dies in a communal riot, an average Hindu says that the country is now one terrorist less. A mindset has been created by communal forces which have resulted in people justifying the killings although they feel sorry when they see an innocent human die in a vehicle accident. This attitude and mindset needs to be changed,” he said.

Canara4

Canara1

Canara5

Canara7

Canara6

Canara3

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
News Network
February 2,2020

Bengaluru, Feb 2: A woman from Bengaluru lost Rs 2.8 lakh to a 'foreign friend' who promised her gifts, including gold jewellery and foreign currency.

Priya, 37, of Banashankari III Stage, told police a man named Bright Wills from England befriended her on social media in December 2019.

On December 20, Wills said he would send gold ornaments and some British pounds as gifts to celebrate their friendship and took her postal address.

“A woman claiming to be an official from the customs office, Delhi, called me on December 21. She told me there was a courier from England in my name and I should pay Rs 75,000 tow ards customs clearance. I believed her and transferred Rs 75,000 to a bank account number provided by her. On December 23, another woman called and said gold ornaments had been sent to me by courier and I had to pay Rs 2.1 lakh towards the paperwork. I transferred the money to another account number mentioned by her," Priya told police.

"On December 25, I received an email which said I should make a surety deposit of Rs 4.3 lakh within 48 hours or else the courier would be sent back to its original destination. I realised I had been cheated by Wills and others. Till now, I have paid Rs 2.8 lakh to them," she claimed.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
coastaldigest.com news network
July 22,2020

Kasaragod, Jul 22: An accused in a POCSO case jumped into the sea at Kasaba Coast near here on Wednesday.

Sources said the accused Mahesh (28), resident of Soorlu Kanhangad, was brought to the groyne ('pulimuttu' in Malayalam) at the coast for collecting evidence.

He escaped from the police and ran around 200 meters towards the sea and jumped into it. The effort to rescue him also failed.

Police, Fire & Rescue officials and fishermen are searching for the body of the accused.

Mahesh was arrested on charge of capturing the video of a minor girl in a washroom on his mobile. 

During interrogation, he had told the copse that he had hidden the mobile, which was used to video record the act, near the groyne. Accordingly, the police had brought him to this place.

Comments

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.
coastaldigest.com news network
January 9,2020

The Bharatiya Janata Party workers belonging to Muslim community are bewildered over the contentious Citizenship Amendment Act. A considerable number of BJP’s Muslim workers have distanced themselves from the pro-CAA meetings being organised by the party in different parts of India.

There is a deep divide within members of the BJP minority wing, with many upset and angry with the party. During its membership drive in 2018 for the minority wing, BJP had enrolled lakhs of Muslims across India.

A senior Muslim member of the saffron party in Hyderabad explained, “We are very upset. There is no one listening to us within the party. Majority of the members are introspecting on their future role in the party. Few are vocal about it. Those, who believe they still have a future in the party, have decided to keep quiet on this issue.”

This is the reason why they are not attending the pro-CAA rallies or interacting with people. If anybody approaches and questions them about CAA, they maintain they have no idea, just like the common man. A member of the BJP belonging to the minority community says they have been hurt by the decision of the government on CAA.

“Shia Muslims in Pakistan are suffering. They have been targeted in that country from time to time. The BJP patronised a large number of Shia Muslims. The Shia community in Uttar Pradesh even sided with the BJP. But what has the community got in the end? The persecuted Shia minorities in Pakistan have not got justice,” the party member from minority community lamented.

There are 400 families belonging to the Shia community in Hyderabad, who have relatives in Karachi and Quetta in Pakistan. These Shias had migrated to Pakistan from the Nizam state after its accession to India. These families were hopeful that after aligning with BJP, there would be a reprieve for them. But the stand taken by BJP has left them in lurch. The CAA provides for granting Indian citizenship only to non-Muslim minorities from Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh.

“We have been left with nothing. Shias have not been politically active in all the three countries of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh and have suffered due to this reason. There was some hope in India, but even that has been lost now,” the minority wing leader remarked.

National vice president of BJP minority cell Farid Sheikh Liaquat Ali says, “Party workers and common people are asking the same question.”

I have told them what union home minister Amit Shah has said in Parliament, that CAA is not against Indian Muslims. But people are not convinced. Every meeting or social function that I attend, I find that people are angry and upset. I have been with the BJP for 33 years and whatever I hear from the people is being conveyed to the party.”

The incident that occurred at the madarasa in Uttar Pradesh has led to a pointed question: “If this can happen to Muslims in UP, will it not repeat elsewhere?”

Comments

Abdullah
 - 
Wednesday, 22 Jan 2020

Dears, how can yu be safe if you are in a cage of dragons + mad dogs + jackals.  Yu betrayed your own community and religion.   You sold yuorself to the enemies for some coins.  Shame on you.  Allah will never accept this and you will get proper treatment.   Sanghis never have trust and courtsey on minorities, dalits, obcs etc.   Dont ever expect anything from these hate guys.  They killed our Father of Nation and you are nothign to them.   They will stab you in your back.   They are misusing you to cheat muslim community.    May be you joined b jp thinking you will get 15 lacs.  You will not get their shit also coz they will use it also.   May Allah bless you with right way of thinking and keep you aware of these anti nationals.  

Prakash SS
 - 
Thursday, 9 Jan 2020

Well done.........Jaise Ko thaisa Mila........Kaisa Maza Ayaa....Now all will come to know about RSS laid BJP this party is not for minor community and poor backward people, this is a party of goondas and criminals, not only Muslims if BJP will be in power even Hindus will not be safe.  we will suffer maximum damage wehen we understand this fact. plesae.... we all have to wake up now. 

Add new comment

  • Coastaldigest.com reserves the right to delete or block any comments.
  • Coastaldigset.com is not responsible for its readers’ comments.
  • Comments that are abusive, incendiary or irrelevant are strictly prohibited.
  • Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name to avoid reject.